The Atlantic

The Very Bad Arguments for Killing the Estate Tax

It’s minuscule, cumbersome, and easily avoided. It's also a symbol of Washington’s approach to dynastic wealth and the American Dream.
Source: Richard T. Nowitz / Getty

The estate tax, which the House GOP bill would repeal and the Senate GOP bill would cut, is a microcosm of a long economic debate in the United States.

One must emphasize here the prefix micro in microcosm. Revenues from the estate tax, which only applies to inheritances worth more than $5.5 million, will account for about $20 billion this year in federal revenues. That’s approximately one-half of 1 percent of the Treasury’s annual haul. Compared to total federal spending, it’s nothing.

But compared to nothing, it’s $20 billion. And the tax code is more than a ledger. It is a national statement of values. And so this little law inspires a great commotion during each tax debate. To its opponents, it is the ultimate (literally) punishment on success and an affront to the family legacy that each striving individual hopes to leave. To

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Trump’s Risky Reaction to the Immunity Decision
This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here. Today, three Atlantic writers explain the Supreme Co
The Atlantic5 min read
The Big Winners of This Supreme Court Term
In three decisions late this week, the Supreme Court upended American administrative law—the legal field that governs how government agencies interpret and implement legislation. Administrative law is notoriously arcane and technical. But these cases
The Atlantic2 min read
Doug Emhoff, First Jazz Fan
Whatever its shortcomings, American society has made two unquestionably great contributions to the world: jazz and constitutional democracy. But the two rarely interact. The typical political attitude toward music is exemplified by Richard Nixon’s de

Related Books & Audiobooks