The Atlantic

The Subtext of Kavanaugh’s Nomination Bursts Into the Open

A sexual-assault allegation against President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee brings the fight over gender and power to the fore.
Source: Alex Wroblewski / Reuters

The last scene of the horror story that is President Trump’s Supreme Court nomination is what any screenwriter would have predicted: a cast of panicky strangers trapped in a haunted house, trying desperately not to say the words that will loose a monster hiding in the walls.

That monster is sex—gender, women’s rights—as lived in America in 2018. From the beginning, gender, and nothing else, is what this confirmation struggle has been about. The nomination of Sandra Day O’Connor in 1981, the first female justice, was a milestone for many women; in 1993, that of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a feminist trailblazer, electrified equal-rights advocates. But neither of those, to me at least, conveyed the ominous gendered subtext of the nomination of Brett Kavanaugh.

Because that is true, there was no way, in the logic of the nightmare that is American life in 2018, that the

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Joe Biden’s ‘Cognitive Fluctuations’
Last Thursday was not a good day for Joe Biden. During the president’s shaky and at times incoherent debate performance, he appeared weaker and frailer in real time than the American public had ever seen. Friday appears to have been a much better day
The Atlantic1 min read
Eustasy
At 90 most of her is thinning, her mind a sheet of paper with perforations. Yesterday she asked five times what year was it exactly? when she bought the car that she still drives and did that year begin with a 19? When the voting signs pop up in the
The Atlantic6 min read
The Supreme Court Puts Trump Above the Law
Near the top of their sweeping, lawless opinion in Trump v. United States, Donald Trump’s defenders on the Supreme Court repeat one of the most basic principles of American constitutional government: “The president is not above the law.” They then pr

Related Books & Audiobooks