The Atlantic

Stop the Impeachment-Polling Madness

A decision to remove the president from office should not turn on public opinion.
Source: Paul Spella / The Atlantic

In a representative democracy, the will of the people always counts. Though elected officials are not obliged to vote in accordance with the will of their constituents, they are obliged to elicit and understand the opinions and circumstances of those whose best interest they serve. 



As for whether that necessitates incessant public-opinion polls on the president’s impeachment and removal—that's a stretch.

In his now-classic impeachment handbook, published just months before President Richard Nixon's resignation in 1974, the late legal scholar Charles Black decried opinion polls on presidential guilt or innocence prior to the Senate vote as an “unspeakable indecency.” The technology of the time served as the starting point of Black’s anxiety: He worried that “continual nationwide television exposure” would create “public pressure for some given result.” In

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Trump’s Risky Reaction to the Immunity Decision
This is an edition of The Atlantic Daily, a newsletter that guides you through the biggest stories of the day, helps you discover new ideas, and recommends the best in culture. Sign up for it here. Today, three Atlantic writers explain the Supreme Co
The Atlantic5 min read
The Big Winners of This Supreme Court Term
In three decisions late this week, the Supreme Court upended American administrative law—the legal field that governs how government agencies interpret and implement legislation. Administrative law is notoriously arcane and technical. But these cases
The Atlantic2 min read
Doug Emhoff, First Jazz Fan
Whatever its shortcomings, American society has made two unquestionably great contributions to the world: jazz and constitutional democracy. But the two rarely interact. The typical political attitude toward music is exemplified by Richard Nixon’s de

Related Books & Audiobooks