The Critic Magazine

Courting disaster

What really gets Sue Gray’s goat is that there is no black and white between public and private or business and pleasure

“I THINK THE PROBLEM IS Boris is running a modern government like a medieval court,” declared Andrew Mitchell MP in the wake of the publication of Sue Gray’s eviscerated report. Instead, he continued, “You need to rule and govern through the structures, through Whitehall, through the Cabinet and National Security Council.”

Setting aside the yah-boo word “medieval”, Mitchell’s description of the Johnson regime as a “court” is accurate, even perceptive. But his critique gets things precisely the wrong way round. It is the “court” aspects of Johnson’s government which have delivered its few notable successes and Mitchell’s much-vaunted formal governmental “structures” which have produced its long catalogue of disasters.

In my article for the , I said that we needed radically to revise our understanding of the premiership. The prime minister was a monarch, I argued, Downing Street a palace and its inhabitants a court. Now, on cue, the revelations of “Partygate”, even in Gray’s bowdlerised account, offer the incontrovertible documentary proof.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Critic Magazine

The Critic Magazine6 min read
The Best We Can Hope For
DANIEL KAHNEMAN DIED ON 27 MARCH AT the age of 90. He was one of the most perceptive and accurate psychologists of the last 100 years, and his analysis of the sorts of mistake we are liable to make when trying to decide what to do is permanently valu
The Critic Magazine4 min read
Whole lotta Love
THE LABEL “DIFFICULT” GETS OVER-used for women, but in Courtney Love’s case, you can say she earned it. At 59, she’s lived every cliché of sex, drugs and rock ’n’ roll, and racked up a list of beefs that makes your average rapper look like a Quaker.
The Critic Magazine2 min read
Medical Science Is Oppressive
“ILLNESS” IS A SOCIAL CONSTRUCT, defined solely (and in negative terms) against its antithesis: “wellness”. Society, in other words, has created the category of “illness” as a means to impose power on those who do not conform to cultural norms of wha

Related Books & Audiobooks