The Caravan

Old Sins

The renowned poet Faiz Ahmed Faiz wrote a short poem in Punjabi about the Partition of 1947:

Kise beejiya ae, tusan waddhna ae
Kise keetiyan ne, tusan wartana ae
Aap wele sir puchhna gichhna si
Hun kise theen ki hisab manggo

Someone sowed, and you shall reap.
Someone did, and you deal with it.
You did not probe, and question
either when it was time.

From whom will you seek explanations now?

Faiz was right. What the earlier generations did, the later generations have to suffer and endure. The partition of India, and, therefore, the partition of Punjab, was carried out by outsiders, without asking the Punjabi people.

But history—the public record or reality—keeps seeking answers from the dead and the living. It is a creature that never shuts up. It sees everything and rubs salt into wounds. It is as the German poet and playwright Bertolt Brecht once wrote: “When the wound stops hurting, what hurts is the scar.”

Punjabis often refer to the partitioned regions as “east” or “west” Punjab, not by the names of the nation states these were included in. Many, especially the families of the displaced, do not commemorate the events of 1947 as azadi, or Independence. They call it vaddey raule—the big riots, the holocaust.

Punjabi authors, writing in Punjabi, Urdu, Hindi and English, have published hundreds of books mourning it. Academic researchers produced, and continue to produce, stacks of theses on it. Painters paint, and there is no count of films. There are five evildoers in these narratives: the viceroy Louis Mountbatten, Mohandas Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru, Mohammed Ali Jinnah and the Akali leader Tara Singh. Every Punjabi chooses a villain

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Caravan

The Caravan1 min read
introducing Caravan Columns
The Caravan brings you regular opinions and analysis from authoritative journalists covering politics, global affairs, healthcare, religion, culture, technology and more. caravanmagazine.in/caravan-columns ■
The Caravan1 min read
The Caravan
EDITOR Anant Nath EXECUTIVE EDITOR Hartosh Singh Bal CONSULTING EDITOR Sushant Singh SENIOR ASSOCIATE EDITOR Puja Sen BOOKS EDITOR Maya Palit CREATIVE DIRECTOR Sukruti Anah Staneley ASSOCIATE EDITOR Ajachi Chakrabarti WEB EDITOR Surabhi Kanga ASSISTA
The Caravan10 min read
Weak Links
“We are just waiting for the Congress,” Nitish Kumar, the chief minister of Bihar, said at a rally in Purnea district, on 25 February. Kumar, who represents the Janata Dal (United), was speaking at the first formal congregation of a new grand allianc

Related Books & Audiobooks