The Christian Science Monitor

Dominion v. Fox: Could case be weaponized against freedom of press?

This week is set to bring a major test of modern freedom of the press in an era of disinformation.

The case of Dominion Voting Systems v. Fox News has its roots in conspiracy theories aired about voting machines after Joe Biden defeated Donald Trump in the 2020 presidential election.

Fox News argues that it was simply airing newsworthy allegations when it repeated those falsehoods. The defamation case brought by Dominion represents a “profound threat to the First Amendment,” Fox’s lawyers argued in a filing. If it loses, the network argues, it would be a journalistic disaster, opening networks and newspapers to all kinds of lawsuits.

In one respect, the outcome is not in doubt: A Delaware judge has already ruled that conspiracy theories about Dominion and its voting machines aired by Fox News are false and constitute defamation per se.

“The statements at issue were dramatically different than the truth,” said Superior Court Judge Eric Davis . “In fact, although it cannot

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Christian Science Monitor

The Christian Science Monitor3 min read
Hurricanes Have Been Strengthening – Like Beryl. Some Scientists Propose A Category 6.
The 2024 U.S. hurricane season, now underway, is predicted to be among the worst in decades. Before the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration made that forecast, a debate had been swirling about whether new vocabulary is needed to reflect t
The Christian Science Monitor5 min readWorld
China’s New World Order: What Xi’s Vision Would Mean For Human Rights, Security
Chinese leader Xi Jinping is pushing forward what he casts as an ambitious blueprint for reshaping the world order, urging developing countries to join Beijing in leading an overhaul of the international system. Over the past year, Beijing’s authorit
The Christian Science Monitor2 min read
Ballots For Kinder Politics
The presidential debates between Joe Biden and Donald Trump should, in theory, help voters better understand the policy differences between each candidate. Yet just as important is deciding which candidate will better help Americans bridge those diff

Related Books & Audiobooks