The Atlantic

What Happened to <em>Wirecutter</em>?

Longtime fans have turned against the product-recommendation website. An evolving internet may be to blame.
Source: Illustration by Joanne Imperio / The Atlantic

This article was featured in One Story to Read Today, a newsletter in which our editors recommend a single must-read from The Atlantic, Monday through Friday. Sign up for it here.

Joe Casabona’s love affair with Wirecutter began in 2013, when the site recommended a pair of inductive winter gloves—the kind that let you interact with a touch screen while staying toasty. They worked well, so he kept going back; he appreciated the rigor of the site’s product reviews. An exhaustive, nearly comical amount of research went into every category: Toilet-paper recommendations were backed by 50 hours of testing. The reviewers were bona fide subject-matter experts or enterprising obsessives who approached finding the best dishwasher with the fervor of crime-scene investigators. This work was documented in the form of sprawling posts, many the length of a magazine feature. Casabona, an audio-gear specialist, remembers thinking he’d found his people. “I really felt I could trust them,” he told me, “and Wirecutter became my go-to.”

I have a similar story, and you might also. It’s why has evolved from a niche website into a cultural phenomenon over its 12 years. (It’s also why you’ll find the same stuff in so many Millennial kitchens.) helped popularize a genre of lucrative recommendation content—where the site gets a cut of every purchase you make after you click on “affiliate” links to Amazon or other partner, there’s a good chance that ’s DNA was in almost every single article you found.

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Joe Biden’s ‘Cognitive Fluctuations’
Last Thursday was not a good day for Joe Biden. During the president’s shaky and at times incoherent debate performance, he appeared weaker and frailer in real time than the American public had ever seen. Friday appears to have been a much better day
The Atlantic1 min read
Eustasy
At 90 most of her is thinning, her mind a sheet of paper with perforations. Yesterday she asked five times what year was it exactly? when she bought the car that she still drives and did that year begin with a 19? When the voting signs pop up in the
The Atlantic6 min read
The Supreme Court Puts Trump Above the Law
Near the top of their sweeping, lawless opinion in Trump v. United States, Donald Trump’s defenders on the Supreme Court repeat one of the most basic principles of American constitutional government: “The president is not above the law.” They then pr

Related Books & Audiobooks