The Threepenny Review

Grace and Gore

I MET GRACE Paley before I'd ever read anything by her. Leonard Michaels invited her to participate in his initial Berkeley Writers Conference, in the summer of 1979, and that was the first time I'd heard of— much less heard—this diminutive, appealing, somewhat grandmotherly soul. She was less than sixty at the time, so she probably wasn't actually a grandmother by then, but something about her felt grandmotherly to me. Perhaps it was her intense New York Jewish accent, the same accent I had heard from my own Flushing-based grandmother (though my grandmother was a harsh, mean, tough-as-nails woman, the very opposite of Grace). Or maybe it's that her delicate, inimitable short stories seemed often to invoke the world of the foreign-born grandmothers.

In the story she allowed me to publish in a 1983 issue of Threepenny, humorously called “In This Country But In Another Language My Aunt Refuses To Marry The Man Everybody Wants Her To,” the rebellious aunt gets the titular role, but the first lines of the story are

My grandmother sat in her chair. She said, When I lie down at night I can't rest, my bones push each other. When I wake up in the morning I say to myself, What? Did I sleep? My God I'm still here. I'll be in this world forever.

The title is humorous in part because it so overwhelms the text with which it appears: three lines of double-columned 24-point Goudy Bold type for a story that takes up less than a quarter of a Threepenny page. But in its thirty-four lines (some of which are very short lines, like “My aunt said, Ach what she saw?” and “What? I asked, What did she see?”), the story manages to convey a full portrait of an immigrant household's daily life, complete with the Yiddish whose rhythms we can hear even though the characters are not actually speaking it.

Grace's stories, all told, filled just three slim volumes: , , and . She always said, when asked, that she wrote very short stories because she could fit them into days that were consumed with other tasks—being a wife and mother, engaging in a lot of community protests and other kinds of political activism, talking on the phone or in person with her friends, becoming a teacher and mentor to young writers, visiting literary conferences… I suppose she must have visited a lot of them, because that is the way I mainly saw her, between the time I met her in 1979 and her death in 2007. I was always delighted to see her, even more so to hear her (she was often giving the keynote speech, in those later years), and she always greeted me with a hug. But

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Threepenny Review

The Threepenny Review4 min read
How Adam Met Eve Outside of a Bar in Queens
IN THE alley behind that Irish pub, Eve asked Adam for a light. Since they were not in Ireland, nor England, nor Europe, for that matter, Adam shrugged. He didn't smoke. Those who did carried e-cigarettes these days. Without words, he told her that h
The Threepenny Review1 min read
Thanks to Our Donors
The Threepenny Review is supported by Hunter College, the Bernard Osher Foundation, Campizondo Foundation, Mad Rose Foundation, and the George Lichter Family Fund. Our writer payments are underwritten by our Writers' Circle, which includes Robert Bau
The Threepenny Review5 min read
A Perfect Bradbury
A CHANCE DISCOVERY at midday. In the library, hidden behind Flaubert's novels, I find—dusty but intact, unseen for more than a quarter of a century—my much-missed, long-lost first issue of the fantasy and science-fiction magazine Minotauro, published

Related Books & Audiobooks