Los Angeles Times

Michael Hiltzik: This huge insurer got caught flouting a law protecting contraceptive access, but its fine is a joke

UnitedHealthcare health insurance company signage is displayed on an office building in Phoenix on July 19, 2023.

There's good news and bad news about a legal settlement that New York state just reached with the giant health insurer UnitedHealth over its denial of contraception coverage for a member, which violated state law.

The good news is that UnitedHealth got caught and has been ordered to reimburse the member — and all others in her situation — for the out-of-pocket costs they incurred.

The bad news is that in addition to the reimbursement order, New York Atty. Gen. Letitia James imposed a penalty of only $1 million on the company.

For UnitedHealth, that's the equivalent of about one-hundredth of a penny based on its annual revenue. In other words, if someone dropped a packet worth of $1 million on the street in front of the company's chairman, he might not even bend over to pick them up for fear of creasing his trousers.

A couple more bits of bad news: Not only is UnitedHealth a "repeat offender" in breaching contraception access laws (in the words

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Los Angeles Times

Los Angeles Times3 min read
U.S. Gymnastics Trials: Frederick Richard Flips His Way To Paris In All-around Triumph
MINNEAPOLIS — The man the internet knows as "Frederick Flips" will be flipping all the way to Paris. Frederick Richard won the all-around at the U.S. Olympic trials on Saturday at Target Center with a two-day all-around score of 170.500 to earn his f
Los Angeles Times4 min read
Appreciation: Comedian, Actor, Musician And Painter Martin Mull Mastered The Art Of Always Being Right For The Job
For anyone lucky enough to have experienced the long arc of his career, the death of droll, dry, deadpan Martin Mull, Thursday at 80, feels like the end of an era. A writer, songwriter, musician, comedian, comic actor and, out of the spotlight, a ser
Los Angeles Times3 min read
Signs Of Avian Flu Found In San Francisco Wastewater
LOS ANGELES — Signs of H5N1 bird flu virus have been detected at three wastewater sites in California’s Bay Area, according to sampling data. While positive wastewater samples have been found in seven other states, California is the only one that has

Related Books & Audiobooks