The Atlantic

The Supreme Court Puts Trump Above the Law

And gives him permission for a despotic second term.
Source: Illustration by The Atlantic. Sources: Al Drago / Bloomberg / Getty; Jabin Botsford / The Washington Post / Getty.

Sign up for The Decision, a newsletter featuring our 2024 election coverage.

Near the top of their sweeping, lawless opinion in Trump v. United States, Donald Trump’s defenders on the Supreme Court repeat one of the most basic principles of American constitutional government: “The president is not above the law.” They then proceed to obliterate it.

Although the pro-Trump justices attempt to nest the breadth of their opinion in legalese, their finding that the president cannot be prosecuted for “official acts,” and that much of Trump’s efforts to seize power fall under that rubric, means that the justices have essentially legalized a losing president refusing to step down, as Trump tried to do after the 2020 election.

The Court’s opinion presents an absurd paradox that defeats the purpose of a constitutional democracy governed by the rule of law. It has

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Biden’s Delegates Are Flirting With a Breakup
Almost a week has passed since Joe Biden’s feeble debate performance. The president’s defenders are sticking with a rehearsed one-two punch: “It was a rough start,” they say, but “let’s focus on substance.” In the opposite corner, Biden’s critics are
The Atlantic4 min read
Hubris of Biblical Proportions
“Kings scarcely recognize themselves as mortals, scarcely understand that which pertains to man,” John Milton wrote, “except on the day they are made king or on the day they die.” Russian President Vladimir Putin is 71; he’s been in power for 12 year
The Atlantic1 min read
Eustasy
At 90 most of her is thinning, her mind a sheet of paper with perforations. Yesterday she asked five times what year was it exactly? when she bought the car that she still drives and did that year begin with a 19? When the voting signs pop up in the

Related Books & Audiobooks