The Atlantic

Something Has Gone Deeply Wrong at the Supreme Court

Jurists who preach fidelity to the Constitution are making decisions that flatly contradict our founding document’s text and ideals.
Source: Damon Winter / The New York Times / Redux

Sign up for The Decision, a newsletter featuring our 2024 election coverage.

Forget Donald Trump. Forget Joe Biden. Think instead about the Constitution. What does this document, the supreme law of our land, actually say about ​​lawsuits against ex-presidents?

Nothing remotely resembling what Chief Justice John Roberts and five associate ​justices declared​ in yesterday’s disappointing Trump v. United States decision​. The Court’s curious and convoluted majority opinion turns the Constitution’s text and structure inside out and upside down, saying things that are flatly contradicted by the document’s unambiguous letter and obvious spirit.​

Imagine a simple hypothetical designed to highlight the key constitutional clauses

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Atlantic

The Atlantic4 min read
Biden Isn’t Listening
At Joe Biden’s rally in Madison, Wisconsin, this afternoon, the men and women who had crammed into a middle-school basketball gym dutifully clapped, yelled words of support, and waved signs bearing the president’s name. But when it came time to chant
The Atlantic9 min read
Why Tucker Carlson Thinks Australia Is Being ‘Taken Away’
On Monday, Tucker Carlson wrapped up the seventh in a series of speeches to right-wing Australian audiences. To attend the event, I had to walk under a bright-pink sign acknowledging that the “traditional owners” of the Melbourne Convention and Exhib
The Atlantic2 min read
Hat Saga
Why did I choose to wear that hat? It was bitter cold, that’s why I wore   The glamorous fur: it covered enough   Of my head to render me anonymous   (I didn’t mean to look mysterious). After the party we hailed a cab, happily   Sped, warm together

Related Books & Audiobooks