M.M. McCabe on the Paradox of Inquiry

FromPhilosophy Bites

Start listening View podcast show

M.M. McCabe on the Paradox of Inquiry

FromPhilosophy Bites

ratings:

Length:

17 minutes

Released:

Dec 14, 2008

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

How do we learn anything? This isn't a puzzle until you start thinking hard about it. In his dialogue The Meno, Plato presented an apparent paradox about inquiry. M.M. McCabe discusses this paradox and its continuing relevance.

Released:

Dec 14, 2008

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (100)

top philosophers interviewed on bite-sized topics

Skip carousel

Angie Hobbs on Plato on War: What causes human agression? For Plato's Socrates it comes from innate tendencies nurtured in the wrong way. And that's where war comes from. Angie Hobbs gives a fascinating introduction to this aspect of Plato's Republic in this episode of Philosophy... by Philosophy Bites
10 min listen
John Cottingham on The Meaning of Life: What is the meaning of life? This is a basic question for all of us. There is also the possibility that life has no meaning whatsoever. In this interview John Cottingham explains his vision of the kinds of meaning that we can find in our lives. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Mary Warnock on Philosophy in Public Life: What can philosophers contribute to public life? Mary Warnock who sits in the House of Lords and has chaired two important commissions discusses how her training in philosophy prepared her for these roles. by Philosophy Bites
13 min listen
Julian Baggini on Thought Experiments: Philosophers often use elaborate thought experiments in their writing. Are these anything more than rhetorical flourishes? Or do they reveal important aspects of the questions under discussion. Julian Baggini, editor of The Philosophers' Magazine and... by Philosophy Bites
12 min listen
Will Kymlicka on Minority Rights: Should minority groups such as recent immigrants or those who have suffered historic injustice be given rights that other citizens don't have? Will Kymlicka believes they should. Listen to his arguments in defence of this position in this episode of... by Philosophy Bites
16 min listen
Simon Blackburn on Plato's Cave: What is the nature of reality? Is the world as it appears, or is there something timeless behind the world of appearances? Simon Blackburn discusses one of the most famous images in Philosophy: Plato's cave. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Chandran Kukathas on Hayek's Liberalism: Friedrich Hayek was a major figure in Twentieth Century economics and political philosophy, but his ideas are sometimes caricatured, not least because Margaret Thatcher approved of his work. Chandran Kukathas explains the key features of his... by Philosophy Bites
13 min listen
Mary Warnock on Sartre's Existentialism: What is existentialism? Is it still relevant to us? Sartre believed that we are free to choose what we make of our lives. Was he right? In this interview for Philosophy Bites Mary Warnock gives her views on Jean-Paul Sartre's existentialism. by Philosophy Bites
12 min listen
Thomas Pink on Free Will: We often blame people for what they do or fail to do. But that implies that they were free to choose whether or not to act in the way they did. At the same time science seems to reveal prior causes of all our actions. There seems little or no room for... by Philosophy Bites
18 min listen
Janet Radcliffe Richards on Men and Women's Natures: Are men and women different by nature? And if so, what follows? Janet Radcliffe Richards, author of The Sceptical Feminist and Human Nature After Darwin, examines questions about human nature, focusing on John Stuart Mill's important book The... by Philosophy Bites
20 min listen
Mary Warnock on the Right to Have a Baby: In this bonus episode produced in association with The Open University, Mary Warnock, a philosopher who also sits in the House of Lords, addresses the question 'Do we have a right to have babies?' A transcript of this episode is available at... by Philosophy Bites
1 min listen
Simon Blackburn on Moral Relativism: Are moral choices simply relative, a matter of culture or taste? Are genuine moral disagreements possible? Should we just tolerate different ways that people choose to live? Nigel Warburton interviews Simon Blackburn on these important... by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Quentin Skinner on Hobbes on the State: What is the state? How do individuals combine to lend legitimate authority to those who act on the state's behalf? These are fundamental questions in political philosophy that Thomas Hobbes addressed in the seventeenth century. In this interview... by Philosophy Bites
18 min listen
David Papineau on Physicalism: Are all our thoughts simply physical events in our bodies? Can we give a purely physical account of the conscious human mind? David Papineau believes that we can. In this interview for Philosophy Bites he explains what physicalism is, why he... by Philosophy Bites
16 min listen
Michael Sandel on Genetic Enhancement in Sport: In this bonus episode of Philosophy Bites made in association with the Open University, Michael Sandel addresses the question of whether we should allow genetic enhancement of athletes. Drawing on themes from his recent book, The Case Against... by Philosophy Bites
17 min listen
G.A. Cohen on Inequality of Wealth: Can differences in income be morally justified? Should we expect rich people to give their money to the poor? G.A. Cohen, author of a book with the provocative title If You're An Egalitarian, How Come You're So Rich? addresses these questions in this... by Philosophy Bites
11 min listen
Peter Singer on Human Use of Animals: In this bonus episode produced in association with the Open University as part of the Ethics Bites series, Peter Singer, perhaps the world's best known living philosopher, discusses how we treat animals. A transcript of this episode is available from... by Philosophy Bites
17 min listen
Richard Norman on Humanism: How can non-believers make sense of the world? How can there be morality without God? In this episode of Philosophy Bites philosopher Richard Norman explains how it is possible to lead a good life without religion. by Philosophy Bites
11 min listen
Donna Dickenson on Body Shopping: Do you own your body? If not, who does? These are important questions in an age in which there is extensive trade in body parts. Donna Dickenson, author of Body Shopping, discusses this issue with Nigel Warburton in this episode of Philosophy Bites. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Peter Millican on Hume's Significance: David Hume is probably the greatest English-speaking philosopher to date. In this interview for Philosophy Bites. Peter Millican, a Hume specialist, explains why his philosophy was so important. by Philosophy Bites
15 min listen
Aaron Ridley on Nietzsche on Art and Truth: Friedrich Nietzsche's ideas about art and truth run through much of his philosophical writing, but are most apparent in his first book, The Birth of Tragedy. In this episode of Philosophy Bites Nigel Warburton interviews Aaron Ridley about this topic. by Philosophy Bites
16 min listen
Stephen Law on The Problem of Evil: What is evil? Is it consistent with the existence of a benevolent God? In this interview Stephen Law gives an original take on this traditional philosophical problem. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Richard Bourke on Edmund Burke on Politics: The eighteenth century thinker and politician Edmund Burke was one of the founders of modern conservativism. In his Reflections on the Revolution in France he attacked the revolution. For this episode of Philosophy Bites Richard Bourke of Queen Mary,... by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Raymond Geuss on Real Politics: Raymond Geuss wants political philosophers to focus on real politics rather than abstract notions. In this interview with Nigel Warburton for Philosophy Bites he explains why he believes philosophers such as Robert Nozick and John Rawls were... by Philosophy Bites
19 min listen
Ray Monk on Philosophy and Biography: Ray Monk discusses the relationship between philosophy and biography in this interview with Nigel Warburton for the Philosophy Bites podcast. Can an understanding the life of a philosopher help us understand that philosopher's work? Is there anything... by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Onora O'Neill on Medical Consent: What do we mean by 'consent' in a medical context? Is it reasonable to ask for informed consent before performing medical procedures? Is consent even the most important issue. Onora O'Neill challenges some widely-held assumptions in this area in this... by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Peter Cave on Paradoxes: Philosophers have been fascinated by paradoxes since ancient times. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast Nigel Warburton interviews Peter Cave about paradoxes and their relevance to philosophy. by Philosophy Bites
16 min listen
Richard Reeves on Mill's On Liberty: In this episode of Philosophy Bites Richard Reeves, author of a recent biography of John Stuart Mill sheds light on Mill's classic defence of individual freedom, On Liberty. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
John Dunn on Locke on Toleration: John Locke, writing in the Seventeenth Century, argued for religious toleration, though stopped short of toleration of atheists. In this episode of the podcast Philosophy Bites, Nigel Warburton interviews Locke expert John Dunn on this topic. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
Anthony Kenny on Aquinas' Ethics: Thomas Aquinas, the thirteenth century Dominican is the subject of this episode of Philosophy Bites. Anthony Kenny explains the key features of Aquinas' ethics in conversation with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen

More Episodes from Philosophy Bites

Skip carousel

Walter Sinnott Armstrong on AI and Morality: Can AI help us make difficult moral decisions? Walter Sinnott Armstrong explores this idea in conversation with David Edmonds in this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast. by Philosophy Bites
14 min listen
David Edmonds on the Life and Philosophy of Derek Parfit: David Edmonds discusses the life and work of Derek Parfit who died in 2017 in this episode of the Bio Bites strand of Philosophy. David is the author of a recent biography of Parfit. by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen
Yascha Mounk on the Identity Trap: Yascha Mounk discusses some of the ways in which focussing on gender, racial, and sexual identities can distort political argument and be counterproductive for oppressed minorities. by Philosophy Bites
31 min listen
Mark Rowe on J.L.Austin: J.L.Austin was the best known exponent of what came to be known as Ordinary Language Philosophy. He was also a war hero. In this episode of the Bio Bites strand of the Philosophy Bites podcast David Edmonds discusses Austin's life and work with his... by Philosophy Bites
23 min listen
James Klagge on Wittgenstein: In this episode James Klagge discusses the life and times of Ludwig Wittgenstein with David Edmonds. This is part of our mini series on the biographies of philosophers, Bio Bites. by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen
David Chalmers on Technophiloosphy and the Extended Mind by Philosophy Bites
18 min listen
Agnes Callard on Sex: What happens when people have sexual desires for one another? from the University of Chicago discusses sex, eroticism, and much more in conversation with Nigel Warburton. Not surprisingly, this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast involves... by Philosophy Bites
17 min listen
Michael Lamb on Augustine on Hope: Augustine is usually described as a pessimist with a bleak view of human evil and corruption. Michael Lamb thinks that is a simplistic reading. Augustine has interesting things to say about hope as a virtue. by Philosophy Bites
19 min listen
Hannah Dawson on Mary Wollstonecraft: In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast Nigel Warburton interviews Hannah Dawson (editor of The Penguin Book of Feminist Writing) on Mary Wollstonecraft and her book A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792). by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen
Seth Lazar on Political Philosophy in the Age of AI: AI has changed our lives already and looks set to have a huge impact. How should we adapt our thinking about political philosophy in the light of this? The philosopher Seth Lazar explores this question in conversation with Nigel Warburton in this... by Philosophy Bites
22 min listen
Scott Hershovitz on Law and Morality: What is the relationship between law and morality? How do they differ? Scott Hershovitz discusses these questions with Nigel Warburton in this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast. by Philosophy Bites
27 min listen
Carissa Veliz on Digital Ethics: Digital ethics is a new field. But what is it, what is its scope? In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast , author of Privacy is Power and editor of The Oxford Handbook of Digital Ethics, discusses these topics with Nigel Warburton.... by Philosophy Bites
23 min listen
Theron Pummer on the Rules of Rescue: You might not have an obligation to risk your life saving other people, but if you do, you should go for saving the greatest number. That's more or less what Theon Pummer believes. Listen to him discussing the morality of rescue with David Edmonds in... by Philosophy Bites
23 min listen
Kieran Setiya on Loneliness: What is loneliness and why is it harmful? How does it differ from just being on your own? In the latest episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast, Kieran Setiya discusses this important with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
19 min listen
William MacAskill on Longtermism: In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast David Edmonds interviews Will MacAskill on the controversial idea that we ought to give the interests of future people substantial weight when deciding what we ought to do now. by Philosophy Bites
22 min listen
Edith Hall on Aristotle's Way: How should we live? This is the basic question for all of us. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast Edith Hall, author of the book Aristotle's Way, gives a sympathetic answer to Aristotle's take on this question. by Philosophy Bites
17 min listen
L.A. Paul on Transformative Experience: We have all had transformative experiences. But do they have philosophical relevance? Laurie Paul believes they do. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast she discusses this fascinating topic with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
18 min listen
Josiah Ober on the Civic Bargain: How do you solve the question of collective self-government by citizens? discusses a fundamental problem of democratic societies: how we come to agree on courses of action when we commit to living within a democracy. His argument is that we need to... by Philosophy Bites
20 min listen
Skye Cleary on Authenticity: Skye Cleary approaches questions of human authenticity throught he lens of French Existentialism, and particularly through Simone de Beauvoir's thought. She is in conversation with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
17 min listen
Peter Railton on AI and Ethics: Developments in AI are coming very quickly. But it's not easy to work out how to deal with the ethical questions that AI generates. Peter Railton discusses AI and Ethics with Nigel Warburton for this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast by Philosophy Bites
25 min listen
Clare Chambers on the Unmodified Body: We all make some modifications to our bodies. But often this is in response to social pressures. So is there something to say for the largely unmodified body? thinks so. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast she spells out why. The... by Philosophy Bites
23 min listen
Peter Singer on Consequentialism: Peter Singer is probably the most famous living philosopher. He recently won the million-dollar Berggruen Prize and promptly gave all that money to charity. His positions on this, on animals, poverty, altruism, and much else besides are... by Philosophy Bites
22 min listen
Cecile Fabre on the Ethics of Spying: Spying raises many ethical issues, but these are rarely discussed - at least by philosophers. Cécile Fabre, author of a recent book on the topic, Spying Through a Glass Darkly, discusses some of these issues with Nigel Warburton in this episode of... by Philosophy Bites
25 min listen
Ro Khanna on Digital Dignity: In this digital age, how can we organise society and the public sphere in ways that will preserve the sense of individual dignity? Ro Khanna, Congressman for Silicon Valley, and author of Dignity in a Digital Age, discusses this important topic with... by Philosophy Bites
19 min listen
Benjamin Lipscomb on 4 Women Philosophers: In Oxford during the Second World War four women philosophers came to prominence. Elizabeth Anscombe, Philippa Foot, Iris Murdoch, and Mary Midgley were friends and met to discuss their ideas, particulary about ethics. Benjamin Lipscomb, author of a... by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen
Paul Bloom on Psychological Hedonism,: Do we seek pleasure and avoid pain? The moral psychologist Paul Bloom believes psychological hedonism gives an inaccurate picture of what motivates us. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast he discusses pain and pleasure with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
20 min listen
Myisha Cherry on Rage: Stoic philosophers described anger as a temporary madness and argued that we should eliminate it wherever possible. More recently Martha Nussbaum has argued for keeping anger out of political debates. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast,... by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen
Agnes Callard on Complaint: We all do it. But is there anything philosophically interesting about complaining? thinks there is. In this episode of the Philosophy Bites podcast she discusses complaint with Nigel Warburton. by Philosophy Bites
26 min listen
Arash Abizadeh on Thomas Hobbes' Ethics: Thomas Hobbes is best known as author of Leviathan which is usually read today for its theory of political authority. Here discusses Hobbes' ethics, the theory of what we are and what are obligations are to each. by Philosophy Bites
21 min listen

Related podcast episodes

Skip carousel

Proust in English by The LRB Podcast
47 min listen
Ep 22: Waking Up Inside The Cave [Pt 2]: Simulation Theory & The Holographic Universe: Today we’re diving into Part 2 of the Waking Up Inside The Cave series. If you haven’t listened to that part 1 yet, I highly recommend that you do so first. It’s linked in the episode brief. For many who take the trip down the UFO rabbit hole, there... by The UFO Rabbit Hole Podcast
50 min listen
82 – Mike Meginnis and Things You Should Do Before You Die by Talking Scared
69 min listen
The End of Everything (Astrophysically Speaking): It’s the end times in this episode as we’re reading The End of Everything (Astrophysically Speaking). In five scenarios, cosmologist Katie Mack explores how the universe might meet its ultimate demise and what this might look like... by Chemistry World Book Club
17 min listen
Humans Are...Trees? — Top 5: Re-Release E2: Humans are like trees. While this thought might not have been at the top of your mind this week, it was a key idea for the biblical authors. In the second of our five most popular podcasts, explore the connection between humans and trees with Tim and Jon as we learn why trees are mentioned more times than almost anything else in the Bible. by BibleProject
69 min listen
Episode 175: At Least We Didn’t Talk About Zombies (Nagel’s “What is it Like to be a Bat?”): We try (with varying success) to wrap our heads around Thomas Nagel’s classic article “What is it Like to be a Bat?" Does science have the tools to give us a theory of consciousness or is that project doomed from the outset? Why do reductionist or functionalist explanations seem so unsatisfying? Is the problem that consciousness is subjective, or is it something about the nature of conscious experience itself? Is this ultimately an epistemological or metaphysical question? What are we talking about? Do we even know anymore? Plus, the return of Mr. Robot! We talk about the big new mystery at the heart of the new season. by Very Bad Wizards
103 min listen
Daniel Schmachtenberger, Jamie Wheal & Jordan Hall: Making Sense about Making Sense of Sensemaking by Decoding the Gurus
217 min listen
26 - Plato's Republic 9: Horny for the Good by Good in Theory: A Political Philosophy Podcast
56 min listen
19.22: Technology and Identity (A Close Reading on Worldbuilding) by Writing Excuses
26 min listen
27. Tenet by Cows in the field
80 min listen
Jessica Moss on Weakness of Will: You think you know what's best but don't do it. We've all been there. For Plato and Aristotle this weakness of will presented a philosophical problem. Jessica Moss explains their contrasting approaches to this topic in this episode of the Philosophy... by Philosophy Bites
13 min listen
16 Dialogue and Dialectic w/ MM McCabe (Philosophy, Plato, Socrates): Philosopher MM McCabe joins us to discuss the art of the philosophical dialogue, both as a literary form and as a practice between people in real-time conversation. What makes Plato's dialogues, for example, worth reading? And is there anything... by Ancient Greece Declassified
40 min listen
Why Matthew McConaughey wrote a children's book about the "paradox of living" by NPR's Book of the Day
7 min listen
GAL04: Expanding Your Consciousness and Reality ft. Mark Gober by Top Traders Unplugged
63 min listen
FLASHBACK: Mothman Starter Guide: Red Eyed Beast or Alien Visitor?: Re-Release of Season 1 Episode 23 by Encounters: A Paranormal Experience
40 min listen
Ep 81: "The Science of Information" (Chiara Marletto's "The Science of Can & Can't" (A prelude to Ch 3): In this the fourth episode about Chiara Marletto's excellent work "The Science of Can and Can't" I discuss the science of information. Chapter 3 of the book is called "Information" but in this episode I do not actually read from the book. This is a broad... by ToKCast
40 min listen
Webcomics - Reviews of Strong Female Protagonist , Existential Comics , and Bucko: Angst Is the Word by The Comics Alternative
79 min listen
A Conversation with...Jeff Meldrum: This episode results from a chance meeting at a g… by Frightday
105 min listen
087: Planet of Dreams by James McKimmey Jr - Sci Fi Short Stories Audiobook by The Lost Sci-Fi Podcast - Vintage Sci-Fi Short Stories
22 min listen
John McDowell Part 2: Squinting to Get a Glimpse of the Real World by On The Very Idea - A Philosophy Podcast
19 min listen
Pokémon The First Movie is Sad! - Talking About Tapes (#45): Since Pokémon Snap is now out, Justin and Newt got together and Pokémon The First Movie: Mewtwo Strikes Back. In this Podcast / Movie Review they will talk about all the things that make it sad. From Mewtwo's existential crisis, the multiple Pokémon... by Hack The Movies
59 min listen
Lance Fortnow by Smart People Podcast
39 min listen
Really Awful Movies: Ep 421 – Exterminators of the Year 3000: On this episode of the Really Awful Movies Podcast, a brief detour and foray into post-apocalyptic wasteland movies. Some movies, like Jaws and Mad Max, are so popular, well made and influential that they spawn a host of imitators. by The Really Awful Movies Podcast
16 min listen
BI 181 Max Bennett: A Brief History of Intelligence: Support the show to get full episodes and join the Discord community. Check out my free video series about whats missing in AI and Neuroscience By day, Max Bennett is an entrepreneur. He has cofounded and CEOd multiple AI and technolo by Brain Inspired
88 min listen
TOVARISCH! (2) by Norman Finkelstein's Podcast
147 min listen
Manga Pulse 489: Skeleton Panties: Bubble trouble? Prepare for muggle and make is subtle. It doesn’t make a whole lot of sense but we’ve already used the Team Rocket speech in an intro as well as quoting the witches from Macbeth. Also coupons and buy one get one free. by Ze Shows – Anime Pulse
99 min listen
The Empty Cage Exhibit Pt. 3 by Aurelius Whitlock's Murder Museum
33 min listen
Andrew Dana Hudson | Voice of Their Generation: Science Fiction by LIGHTSPEED MAGAZINE - Science Fiction and Fantasy Story Podcast (Sci-Fi | Audiobook | Short Stories)
23 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

M.M. McCabe on the Paradox of Inquiry

M.M. McCabe on the Paradox of Inquiry

Description

Titles in the series (100)

More Episodes from Philosophy Bites

Related podcast episodes