Bava Kamma 57: Shomer Sacher vs Shomer Chinam

FromTalking Talmud

Start listening View podcast show

Bava Kamma 57: Shomer Sacher vs Shomer Chinam

FromTalking Talmud

ratings:

Length:

14 minutes

Released:

Dec 29, 2023

Format:

Podcast episode

Description

The daf explores a disagreement between Rabbah and Rav Yosef over the status of person watching a lost object. Rabbah compares this to a Shomer chinam who is not liable if the object is lost or stolen. Rav Yosef compares this to a Shomer Sacher who would be liable if the object is lost or stolen.

Released:

Dec 29, 2023

Format:

Podcast episode

Titles in the series (100)

Learning the daf? We have something for you to think about. Not learning the daf? We have something for you to think about! (Along with a taste of the daf...) Join the conversation with us!

Skip carousel

Introduction and Berakhot 2 by Talking Talmud
12 min listen
Berakhot 5: The Problem of Evil by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Berakhot 26: Now We Have Prayer by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Berakhot 18: Death Be Not Proud by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Berakhot 8: The Dramatic Innovation of Those 4 Cubits of Halakhah by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Berakhot 25: We're Not Angels by Talking Talmud
15 min listen
Berakhot 10: Beruriah and Praying from the Depths by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Berakhot 20: Generation Gaps by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Berakhot 4: Moshe, David, and Redemption by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Berakhot Daf 3: When the dog barked, it was much later than midnight by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Berakhot 11: "Your beard is very full" - A Matter of Debate by Talking Talmud
13 min listen
Berakhot 22: What Can a Ba'al Keri Who Hasn't Dunked Do? by Talking Talmud
15 min listen
Berakhot 48: When Abaye and Rava Were Little Kids by Talking Talmud
24 min listen
Berakhot 14: If women don't lay tefilin, can they say Shema? by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Berakhot 16: The Shema You Recite Up in a Tree by Talking Talmud
12 min listen
Berakhot 41: A Barley-grain-sized Piece of Bone from a Corpse (Understanding the 7 Species) by Talking Talmud
23 min listen
Berakhot 6: Encountering God by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Berakhot 19: The Case of Kilayim and Stripping in the Marketplace by Talking Talmud
22 min listen
Berakhot 7: Blessing God by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Berakhot 28: Leadership and the Value of Machloket by Talking Talmud
32 min listen
Shabbat 2 use this link by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Berakhot 13: Focusing Your Heart by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Berakhot 12: How Wrong Is Wrong? by Talking Talmud
18 min listen
Berakhot 24: Naked! by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Berakhot 15: What If You Don't "Hear" Shema? by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Berakhot 34: God Knows Who You're Praying For by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Berakhot 33: Lions and Snakes and Scorpions, Oh My! by Talking Talmud
26 min listen
Berakhot 21: It Takes 10 to Make a Minyan by Talking Talmud
18 min listen
Berakhot 9: Different Opinions (Shocking, We Know) by Talking Talmud
22 min listen
Berakhot 46: God's Favor: The Corpses Did Not Decompose by Talking Talmud
22 min listen

More Episodes from Talking Talmud

Skip carousel

Bava Batra 10: Rabbit Chanina ben Tryadon’s Tzedakah by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Batra 9: Tzedakah by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Batra 8: Rabbinic Exemptions by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Batra 7: Why Elijah Stopped Visiting by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Bava Batra 6: Talmudic Building Code - Take 2 by Talking Talmud
18 min listen
Bava Batra 5: Ravina vs. Ronya by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Bava Batra 4: The Last Hasmonean, Preserved in Honey by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Bava Batra 3: Talmudic Building Code by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Bava Batra 2: A Partition or a Division by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Bava Metzia 119: Roots and Leaves by Talking Talmud
11 min listen
Bava Metzia 118: Public Damages by Talking Talmud
15 min listen
Bava Metzia 117: I Did Not Sign Up for This by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Bava Metzia 116: Upstairs Downstairs by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Bava Metzia 114: A Graveyard visit with Eliyahu by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Metzia 115: The Milestone by Talking Talmud
15 min listen
Bava Metzia 113: One Bed Two Bed by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Bava Metzia 112: Craftspeople Deserve Their Wages by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Bava Metzia 111: Oshek and Gezel by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Bava Metzia 110: Payday by Talking Talmud
13 min listen
Bava Metzia 109: Down By the Sycamore Tree by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Bava Metzia 108: Bar Meitzra by Talking Talmud
14 min listen
Bava Metiza 107: How Do You Take Your Morning Bread? by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Metzia 105: Little House on the Prairie and Unsuccessful Crops by Talking Talmud
12 min listen
Bava Metzia 106: Crop Failures and Their Many Consequences by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Metzia 104: Lashon Hedyot by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Bava Metzia 103: Sharecroppers and Tenant Farmers by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Bava Metzia 102: Shiluach HaKan by Talking Talmud
19 min listen
Bava Metzia 101: Uprooted Trees and Evicted Homes by Talking Talmud
17 min listen
Bava Metzia 100: Oath-taking to Establish a Sale (except for slaves) by Talking Talmud
21 min listen
Bava Metzia 99: 50 Dates Minus 1 by Talking Talmud
17 min listen

Related podcast episodes

Skip carousel

Bava Metzia 9 - March 8, 28 Adar 1: Today's daf is sponsored by Rikki and Alan Zibitt in loving memory of Helen Zibitt on her 24th yahrzeit. "Mom was a devoted and loving mother, grandmother and great-grandmother, who lived a life filled with middot, chesed, learning and ahavat Yisrael.... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
46 min listen
Bava Kamma 77 - January 18, 8 Shvat: Today's daf is sponsored by Zeev Segal, Chaya Sara Nisan and Naomi Noi in loving memory of Rabbi Shmuel Halevi Segel. Today's daf is sponsored by Sara Averick and Jose Rosenfeld in loving memory of Sara's brother, Moshe David ben Naftali Yosef... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
40 min listen
Bava Metzia 11 - Rosh Chodesh Adar 2 - March 10, 30 Adar 1: Today's daf is sponsored by Emma and Richard Rinberg in honor of the engagement of their son Joseph to Shachar, daughter of Ayelet and Amir Yefet of Shoham. After concluding that everyone agrees that if a husband puts a get in his wife's courtyard,... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
45 min listen
Chagigah 5: Seeing the Pain in God's Hidden Face by Talking Talmud
20 min listen
Eruvin 66 - October 14, 26 Tishrei: Today's daf is dedicated in memory of Avraham Nachum ben Yitzchak Refael z"l on his yahrzeit. His dedication to Daf Yomi is an inspiration to his family, who continue in his footsteps. And by Debbie and Michael Schreiber in honor of our first... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
41 min listen
Kiddushin 52 - October 4, 19 Tishrei: Today's daf is sponsored by Ira and Natanya Slomowitz in loving memory of their father and father-in-law, haRav Shlomo ben Mashsa v'haRav Dov Tzvi Slomowitz. A final (sixth) source is brought in an attempt to raise a difficulty with Rava's opinion... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
46 min listen
Yevamot 84 - May 30, 29 Iyar: Today’s daf is sponsored by David Wenner in honor of Yaffa (Wenner) joining Hadran’s Daf Yomi. “From your loving family." Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak brings further support for the assertion made that even though Rabbi Eliezer ruled that an... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
47 min listen
Eruvin 50: The Time Rav Argued with a Beraita by Talking Talmud
23 min listen
Bava Metzia 46 - April 14, 6 Nissan: Today's daf is dedicated to the safety of Israel from the Iranian attack. Today's daf is sponsored by Mitzi and David Geffen in loving memory of Mitzi's mother, Ruth Toll Lock, Rut bat Miriam and Avraham z"l on her 38th yahrzeit. "She was a... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
46 min listen
Bava Metzia 48 - April 16, 8 Nissan: Today's daf is sponsored by the Sosland family in loving memory of Rabbi Henry Sosland, z"l. "Dad, we strive every day to live by your values, especially your devotion to family, to learning, and to am Yisrael. Am Yisrael Chai!" Today's daf is... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
46 min listen
Bava Kamma 65 - Shabbat January 6, 25 Tevet: Rav held that a thief repays a stolen item based on the price of the item at the time of the theft and the double payment and the four/five times payment based on the price at the judgment. Rav Sheshet raises two difficulties against Rav from braitot,... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
42 min listen
Bava Metzia 36 - April 4, 25 Adar 2: Rabbi Yirmia brings various situations where one borrows and lends to another and they can both be obligated to bring either a sin or a guilt offering or one a sin and one a guilt. What are the various situations? Can a shomer give an item to someone... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
40 min listen
Bava Metzia 8 - March 7, 27 Adar 1: Today's daf is sponsored by Rochel Cheifetz in loving memory of her aunt, Rose Rubelow, Rachel bat haRav Moshe v'Tzipora Mashbaum whose yartzeit was 26 Adar. When the law is to split an item, the meaning is to split the market value. There are... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
44 min listen
Shabbat 4: Today's shiur is sponsored by Rebecca Schwarzmer in honor of her beloved grandmother Frances Rabitz Brauner, Fruma Malka bat Avraham v'Penina z"l. Why in our mishna are they obligating even if the space where the object is placed and also uprooted... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
39 min listen
Yevamot 52 - Yom HaShoah - April 28, 27 Nissan: Today’s daf is dedicated for Yom HaShoah in memory of all those who died in the Holocaust. Today's daf is sponsored by Lenore Davis in honor of her parents, Rabbi Ruby Davis ztl and Susan Davis. "They prioritized torah learning in our home. With... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
45 min listen
Ketubot 73 - Shabbat September 17, 21 Elul: Rav and Shmuel disagree in a case where a man betroths a woman with a stipulation that she does not have vows. If he then marries her without making the same stipulation, and she is found to have vows, does she need a get from him or not? Abaye... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
37 min listen
Yevamot 83 - Yom Yerushalayim, May 29, 28 Iyar: Today's daf is dedicated in honor of the city of Jerusalem for Yom Yerushalayim. Celebrating 55 years since its unification. Today’s daf is sponsored by Rebecca Darshan in loving memory of her mother, Helene Isaacs, Chana bat Avraham David and... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
47 min listen
Nedarim 7 - November 1, 7 Cheshvan: Today's daf is sponsored by Rochelle Cheifetz in loving memory of her paternal grandmother’s yahrzeit, Esther bat Avraham. Today's daf is dedicated in memory of Rabbi Meir Shapiro, the Daf Yomi visionary, on his 89th yahrzeit. Rav Papa continues to... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
47 min listen
Kiddushin 53 - October 5, 20 Tishrei: This week's daf is sponsored by Sarah Zahavi for the refuah shleima of Tinok ben Talia Nechama. Today's daf is sponsored by Tova and David Kestenbaum in honor of the birth of their grandson Naveh Eitan, son of their children Avital and Dvir Gamliel.... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
50 min listen
Yevamot 11 - Shushan Purim, March 18, 15 Adar 2: This week's daf is sponsored by Ira and Natanya Slomowitz for the refuah shleima of Dvora Diener, Dvora Rachel bat Ahuva and Harav Shlomo. Today's learning is sponsored by Hadran Women of Long Island in honor of Hadran and Rabbanit Michelle for her... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
49 min listen
Gittin 22 - June 7, 18 Sivan: Today's daf is sponsored by the Hadran Women of Long Island as a zechut for a refua shelaima bikarov for Yakira Liba bat Sara Gita, beloved granddaughter of our friend Tzippy Wolkenfeld. May our learning be a zechut for her and all cholei Yisrael. Can... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
46 min listen
Behar 5784 - Unexpected Ribbis by The Weekly Alumni Shiur
18 min listen
Yevamot 45: Was Rav a Bigot? (God forbid, of course) by Talking Talmud
16 min listen
Gittin 6 - May 22, 2 Sivan: Is Babylonia considered like Israel for gittin and therefore one who brings from place to place in Babylonia would not need to say "in front of me it was written..."? Rav and Shmuel disagree about this. First, they suggest that the root of the debate... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
48 min listen
Pesachim 52 - January 12, 28 Tevet: Today’s Daf is sponsored by Gabrielle Altman in memory of Rabbi Ruby Davis z"l, "beloved father of Debby Rapps, who was in his 7th cycle of Daf Yomi, and Rabbi Moshe Rapps z"l, beloved father of AZ Rapps, who inspired thousands with a love of Torah... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
43 min listen
Sukkah 36 - August 12, 4 Elul: Today's daf is sponsored by Emma Rinberg in memory of her beloved mum, Marjorie Glick, Miriam Chana bat Menachem Mendel and Rachel on the occasion of her stone setting and shloshim. "May her precious neshama glow brightly in the zechut of our learning... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
38 min listen
Eruvin 32 - September 10, 21 Elul: Today's daf is dedicated by Art Gould to the health, healing and well-being of his beloved bride of 47 years, Carol Robinson - Karina Gola bat Huddah. "Carol has been my best friend and partner, mother to our daughters, bubbe to our grand-daughter and... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
45 min listen
Yevamot 45 - April 21, 20 Nissan: Today's daf is dedicated by Deborah Hoffman-Wade "in grateful appreciation for my 90-year-old mother, Geraldine Hoffman, who gave birth to me 69 years ago today. She continues to be a blessing!" What is the status of a child born to a non-Jewish... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
48 min listen
Shabbat 94 - June 8, 16 Sivan: Today's daf is dedicated in memory of Dvora bat Moshe vRachel z"l by Josh Kirsch and by Michael Lawrence in honor of his wife, Lisa's on her birthday. He is very proud of your dedication to learning daf yomi and wishes you many more years of continued... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
48 min listen
Nedarim 84 - January 17, 24 Tevet: Today’s daf is sponsored by Adrienne Robb-Fund in honor of her friend and chavruta, Joanna Rom, on her birthday! Today’s daf is sponsored by Idana Goldberg on the first yahrzeit of Meyer Weitz, Meir Ben Yehoshua v’Leah. “An Orthodox... by Daf Yomi for Women - Hadran
41 min listen

Discover this podcast and so much more

Bava Kamma 57: Shomer Sacher vs Shomer Chinam

Bava Kamma 57: Shomer Sacher vs Shomer Chinam

Description

Titles in the series (100)

More Episodes from Talking Talmud

Related podcast episodes